Welcome to the Three20 forums! Before you dive too deep into things, please read our forum rules.
iPad app rejected for jiggly icon when launchpad pressed down.
  • Vote Up0Vote Down GeekDadGeekDad August 2011
    Posts: 3

    9.2

    Additionally, we found that your app includes a feature, or features, that mimic an iOS interface or behavior, which is not in compliance with the App Store Review Guidelines.

    The Game Feed icons present in the main page jiggle after being pressed down, mimicking the behavior of icons on the iOS homescreen. We've included screenshots to help identify the feature in question.

    It would be appropriate to remove or revise these features to make them distinctly different from the iOS behaviors and interfaces to avoid causing user confusion. While the guideline specifies iPod interfaces, the spirit of the guideline includes all iOS interfaces and behaviors.

    I think i got a reviewer on a bad day! Telling me that this functionality is a breaks IOS guidelines.

    Submitted to review board.. see what happens with the appeal. if not, anyone know how to nix the jiggle?

  • 5 Comments sorted by
  • Vote Up0Vote Down PEZPEZ August 2011
    Posts: 19PEZ

    I have this in my TTLauncherView subclass:

    - (void)editHoldTimer:(NSTimer*)timer {
  _editHoldTimer = nil;
}

    Don't know if that's the proper way to do it. Additionally I might add that for me deleting items didn't make sense in my launcher view so I wanted to get rid of that behavior completely. If you still need the items to be editable, then I guess you need to go a different route. I've seen that jiggle code when browsing the source so I don't think it's hard to just override one method to stop the jiggle.

    That said, I think the reviewer is in the wrong here and that the review board will straighten him/her up.

    /PEZ
  • Vote Up0Vote Down zhiyongchiuzhiyongchiu December 2011
    Posts: 2

    how to let button don't jiggle ??

  • Vote Up0Vote Down zhiyongchiuzhiyongchiu December 2011
    Posts: 2

    find below and mark pass it ~ [self wobble] ;

  • Vote Up0Vote Down phillipuniversephillipuniverse December 2011
    Posts: 164phillipuniverse

    Yes, the reviewer is definitely in the wrong. I just submitted an app last week with the current 1.0.9 version of Three20 and had no issues getting it approved.

  • Vote Up0Vote Down yoojinyoojin February 2012
    Posts: 1

    FYI,

    Maye this will help others.

    Just now, the initial submission for a Lite App was rejected for jiggly delete icons too as well as having too much of a Springboard-like interface.

    The appeal failed too. The reviewer seemed to be insistent on rejecting the Lite App for seemingly petty/ill-formed?? reasons prior. Which I had appealed successfully.

    Strangely the full version never had a problem with over 11 reviews and just started to get an issue with the latest submission.

Add a Comment

Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!

Login with Facebook Sign In with Twitter

Sign In Apply for Membership

Categories

In this Discussion

Tagged

Latest Three20 version: 1.0.5

Who's Online (0)